We played with a random Supply from the base Dominion game and added the three promo cards to the randomizer deck.

The Supply consisted of:

Black Market, Chapel, Council Room, Feast, Gardens, Mine, Thief, Village, Witch, Woodcutter

Although I liked a Gardens strategy for this Supply given all the actions that might bring you more cards, I tried a Chapel strategy. I mixed in the Black Market and snagged a Moat, Cellar and Library. Things went ok but not quite well enough as Jeff and Meredith tied with Jeff winning the tie-break.

Scores:
Me – 31
Meredith – 40
Jeff – 40
Jim – 18

This time I knew what to do. Go with my gut and use the Gardens/Woodcutter/Thief combo. I was satisfied when three Supply piles were gone, I had 51 cards in my deck and sweet victory!

Scores:
Me – 44
Meredith – 26
Jeff – 16
Jim – 17